WASHINGTON — Shortly after Boeing CEO Dave Calhoun took his seat Tuesday, families who lost relatives in the 2018 and 2019 crashes of the company’s 737 Max 8 planes called out to him, demanding that he turn around and acknowledge them and the photos of their loved ones.
Among those behind Calhoun were the parents and brother of Samya Rose Stumo, the 24-year-old who was killed in the 2019 Ethiopian Airlines accident and a grandniece of Ralph Nader, the consumer advocate and former presidential candidate. Nearby sat the family of John Barnett, the former Boeing engineer and whistleblower who died by suicide earlier this year in the midst of a Justice Department criminal investigation into the company. Others held photos of their loved ones lost in the crashes.
“I would like to apologize, on behalf of all of our Boeing associates spread throughout the world, past and present, for your losses,” Calhoun said while facing the families. “And I apologize for the grief that we have caused.”
The hearing was Calhoun’s first appearance before Congress since a January incident in which the door plug of a 737 Max 9 plane ripped off during an Alaska Airlines flight at an elevation of about 16,000 feet near Portland, Oregon.
Calhoun, who plans to step down at the end of the year, took over as CEO in 2019 after two fatal crashes of a smaller version of the jet, the 737 Max 8. Those crashes, in which 346 people died, led to a 20-month global ban on the plane.
Members of a Senate investigative panel questioned Calhoun about reports of the company retaliating against whistleblowers who raised safety and quality concerns, how parts made of questionable titanium made it into Boeing planes without detection and allegations of falsified inspection records involving the company’s 787 Dreamliner.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., chair of the subcommittee holding the hearing, said Calhoun had assured lawmakers that he was the leader Boeing needed to turn the corner after the Max crashes in 2018 and 2019. Blumenthal said the company had appeared to be heading in the right direction until the January incident, which he said exposed shortcuts the company had been taking.
“This past January, the facade quite literally blew off the hollow shell that had been Boeing’s promises to the world,” Blumenthal said. “And once that chasm was exposed, we learned that there was virtually no bottom to the void that lay below.”
Sen. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., criticized Calhoun and said he had failed to foster a culture of transparency and safety at Boeing, noting how the company has come under intense federal scrutiny under his leadership. Hawley told Calhoun that he is not meeting the standards needed to justify his vast annual salary.
“You are under investigation for falsifying 787 inspection records,” Hawley said. “Boeing is under criminal investigation for the Alaska Airlines flight. You were investigated by DOJ for criminal conspiracy to defraud the FAA — this is all under your tenure. This doesn’t sound like transparency to me.”
In response to tough initial questioning from Blumenthal, Calhoun accepted responsibility for the crashes during his testimony.
“I accept that MCAS and Boeing are responsible for those crashes,” Calhoun said. “We are responsible.” MCAS stands for Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System, a flight-stabilizing feature that caused the 2018 and 2019 crashes.
In its report, the subcommittee cited several whistleblowers, including one who first publicly shared his concerns with The New York Times. The whistleblowers accused the company of failing to track unapproved parts and, in some cases, even allowing those components onto the production line.
One whistleblower, Sam Mohawk, who works as a quality inspector in the factory where Boeing assembles the Max, told the committee that the company had lost track of hundreds of unapproved Max parts and “intentionally hid” improperly stored components from the Federal Aviation Administration during an inspection last summer.
The subcommittee also said that Boeing had engaged in what it described as a “yearslong effort” to cut quality inspections.
“We received this document late Monday evening and are reviewing the claims,” Boeing said in a statement. “We continuously encourage employees to report all concerns as our priority is to ensure the safety of our airplanes and the flying public.”
On May 30, Boeing outlined a required plan to the FAA on how it would address safety and quality concerns that emerged after the door plug incident. Last week, the FAA and European Union Aviation Safety Agency said they were investigating how titanium with falsified documentation made it onto Boeing and Airbus planes.
The lawmakers at the hearing largely expressed displeasure and skepticism. Blumenthal told the Times after the hearing that he was “highly dissatisfied” with Calhoun’s “evasive answers.” The senator also said the committee would take “appropriate action” if Calhoun failed to respond with follow-up answers.
“We have ways of compelling information,” Blumenthal said. “And we will expect documents as well as answers from him personally.”
The family members who attended the hearing said they were unimpressed and unmoved by Calhoun’s apology and his stated commitment to safety and transparency. One of them told reporters that Calhoun avoided making eye contact and quickly left after the hearing concluded.
© 2024 The New York Times Company